The North Fork of Long Island is widely regarded for its rich agricultural history that has created a thriving farm-to-table dining scene. From classic seafood shacks to modern farm-to-table restaurants, the North Fork offers a diverse range of dining options that showcase the region’s fresh, locally sourced ingredients.
Whether you’re a local or a visitor, exploring the essential restaurants on the North Fork is a must-do experience for anyone who loves to eat great food. In this guide, we’ll highlight some of the top-rated and most popular restaurants on the North Fork from Baiting Hollow to East Marion that offer delicious cuisine, unique ambiance, and a taste of the region’s rich culinary heritage.
Barrow Food House
Aquebogue
Barrow Food House is a farm-to-table restaurant located in Aquebogue, North Fork Long Island. The restaurant is situated in a converted farmhouse and has a cozy and rustic ambiance.
The menu at Barrow Food House features seasonal and locally sourced ingredients, with a focus on farm-to-table cuisine. They work with local farmers and fishermen to ensure that each dish is made with the freshest ingredients available.
Some of the signature dishes at Barrow Food House include their Crispy Brussels Sprouts, Spaghetti Squash Latkes, and their famous Smash Burger. They also have a selection of craft cocktails, beer, and wine to complement their food. Barrow Food House has a Kids Menu so you can bring the whole family!
In addition to their delicious food and drinks, Barrow Food House also has a beautiful outdoor patio that is perfect for dining during the warmer months. The patio, also pet-friendly, is surrounded by beautiful greenery and has a cozy ambiance, making it the perfect spot to relax and enjoy a meal. (631) 779-3379
Bruce & Son
Greenport
Bruce & Son is a popular restaurant and bakery located in Greenport on the North Fork. It is a family-owned business that offers a unique dining experience with a focus on fresh, local ingredients and creative cuisine.
The restaurant has a cozy, rustic ambiance with a welcoming atmosphere. They serve breakfast and lunch, with a variety of dishes that are made from scratch using locally sourced ingredients. The menu features a variety of savory and sweet items, including homemade pastries, sandwiches, soups and salads.
Some of the signature dishes at Bruce & Son include their brioche French toast, avocado toast, and their famous bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich on a homemade biscuit. They also offer a variety of vegetarian and gluten-free options. Bruce & Son offers signature cocktails such as the Compassion, which is made with vanilla bean, passion fruit, and vodka.
Bruce & Son is known for their bakery, which offers a variety of homemade pastries, cakes, and bread. They also offer a selection of artisanal coffee and tea. (631) 323-6623
Cooperage Inn
Baiting Hollow
The Cooperage Inn is a well-known restaurant located in Baiting Hollow. It is a family-owned business that has been serving customers for over 70 years. The restaurant is situated on a 30-acre property and has a spacious dining room, a cozy bar, and an outdoor patio with beautiful views of the countryside.
The Cooperage Inn is known for its classic American cuisine, featuring a variety of dishes made from locally sourced ingredients. They offer an extensive menu that includes seafood, poultry, and steak, as well as seasonal specials. The restaurant also has an extensive wine list featuring local Long Island wines and international selections.
Some of the signature dishes at the Cooperage Inn include their oversized Waldorf Salad, Seafood Bisque, Chicken Pot Pie, and their famous prime rib.
Cooperage Inn also hosts events and weddings on their property. They have several banquet rooms and can accommodate large groups for private events. (631) 727-8994
First and South
Greenport
First & South is situated in a historic building that dates back to the mid-19th century. The menu features seasonal, farm-to-table cuisine that showcases the region’s fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The restaurant sources its ingredients from local farmers and fishermen, ensuring that each dish is made with the freshest ingredients available. The menu changes seasonally to take advantage of the best local produce.
The restaurant serves brunch, lunch, and dinner, with a menu that includes a variety of dishes that are made from scratch in-house. Some of the signature dishes at First & South include their crispy Brussels sprouts, Shrimp and Grits, and the famous First & South burger. They also have a cocktail list that includes favorite like the Aperol Spritz and their signature “The Fancy”.
In addition to their delicious food and drinks, First & South also has a beautiful outdoor patio that is perfect for dining during the warmer months. The patio is surrounded by beautiful greenery and has a cozy ambiance, making it the perfect spot to relax and enjoy a meal. (631) 333-2200
Grana
Jamesport
Grana Trattoria is an Italian restaurant located in Jamesport. From wood fired pizza to handmade pasta, Grana has an inviting menu and atmosphere. For almost 14 years this restaurant has been a fan favorite on the east end.
With food inspired from the north Dolomites to the south of Sicily, Grana’s dishes are anything but lacking flavor. They have wood fired pizza of the classics you love as well as organic salads. They are famous for their regional pastas which include Uovo di Ravioli and Busiate Trapanese.
The dishes at Grana will transport you to the regions of Italy. A menu created with organic and locally souced ingredients is not one to miss! Grana is available to make reservations at by phone call and email every Wednesday after 3:30. 631.779.2844
Goodfood.
Mattituck
Goodfood Café and Market is located in the heart of Long Island Wine Country. You can find this quaint sport just off of Love Lane in Mattituck. Using fresh and local ingredients, the owner Luchi Masliah creates signature dishes you’ll want to try.
Goodfood’s menu has a plethora of options, from breakfast foods and smoothies to sandwiches and empanadas. They also have prepared foods including a kale salad and a Moroccan chickpea salad. Goodfood has a variety of empanadas to choose from; these include BBQ pork and mango, spinach and feta cheese, black bean and corn, and more. Goodfood also has a kids menu so everyone is welcome!
Housemade cookies and bread pudding are a must at the end of your meal. Goodfood also offers a catering menu with even more choices. Orders can be made online or calling ahead. (631) 298-7599
The Halyard
Greenport
The Halyard at the Sound View Hotel in Greenport is another essential restaurant on the North Fork. Using ingredients from local farmers and fishermen, this restaurant strives to create dishes that are both modern and classic. Deep Roots Farm, Oysterponds Shellfish, and Ira at KK’s The Farm are those who contribute to the delicious cuisine at the Halyard. Not only can you dine at the Halyard, but you can book a weekend vacation at the Sound View Hotel!Â
The Halyard’s brunch menu includes dishes such as Croque Madame and Stuffed French Toast. They also have shrimp cocktail and oysters to have as appetizers. As for their dinner menu, their appetizers include Whipped Truffle Ricotta and Short Rib Arancini, as well as other mouthwatering dishes. The main dishes are comprised of Pan Seared Sea Scallops, Panko Crusted Halibut, a Hot Lobster Roll and more.Â
The Halyard also has the Piano Bar that is open Thursday-Friday from 5 pm – 8 pm and weekends from 12 pm – 8 pm. This is a perfect spot to have a cocktail before dinner or even enjoy some appetizers. The Haylard has brunch every weekend from 11 am – 3 pm and dinner Thursday – Sunday from 5 pm – 8 pm. They also have to-go dining options. Reservations can be made on Open Table. (631) 477-0666
Hellenic Snack Bar & Restaurant
East Marion
The Hellenic Snack Bar & Restaurant is a family-owned Greek restaurant located in East Marion. It has been serving customers for over 30 years and is well known for its delicious and authentic Greek cuisine.
The restaurant has a warm and welcoming atmosphere, with a cozy indoor dining room and an outdoor patio that overlooks a beautiful garden. The menu at Hellenic Snack Bar & Restaurant features a variety of traditional Greek dishes.
Some of the signature dishes at Hellenic Snack Bar & Restaurant include their Greek salad, Spanakopita, and Moussaka. They also offer a variety of grilled meats, seafood, and vegetarian dishes, as well as homemade desserts. Hellenic Snack Bar also has a kids menu so the entire family can enjoy! Some of their signature cocktails include the Hail Mary and the Frappetini.
Hellenic Snack Bar & Restaurant also has a specialty food market where customers can purchase imported Greek products, including olive oil, cheese, and other specialty items. (631) 477-0138
Modern Snack Bar
Aquebogue
Modern Snack Bar in Aquebogue has been another crowd-pleaser since the 1950s. Though it came from humble beginnings and started off small, Modern Snack Bar has grown in size and popularity since then!
As a family owned restaurant, their food is bound to be something special. Some of their popular meals include soft shell crab, key lime garlic oysters, and bay scallops. They have a wide variety of seafood selections in most of their dishes. Modern Snack Bar also has great sandwiches including the grilled tuna melt and the North Fork reuben.
Not only is the good great, but their dessert and milkshakes are on par. They have fresh baked pies and cakes that are bound to leave you fulfilled. Modern Snack Bar doesn’t take reservations, but they offer take out. (631) 722-3655
PORT Waterfront Bar & Grill
Greenport
PORT Waterfront Bar & Grill is the ideal summer dining spot. This is the perfect location for lunch with the family or a romantic sunset dinner. Located in Greenport with fantastic views of the water, this seaside restaurant is a must-try!
PORT Waterfront Bar & Grill’s menu has a variety of summer favorites. The lobster cobb salad is a must try, as well as their baked clams. Their North Fork lobster roll is a must, putting a twist on the classic rolls we already know. There is an assortment of cocktails to try that are refreshing on a summer night!
To dine at the PORT Waterfront Bar & Grill, you can make a reservation online or by calling the restaurant. 631-333-2501
Star Confectionery
Riverhead
The Star Confectionery is a nostalgic restaurant and candy store located in downtown Riverhead on East Main Street. It has been a local landmark since it was established in 1920 and is known for its classic American diner fare for breakfast and lunch.
The restaurant has a charming retro ambiance, with a counter and stools, booths, and a few tables. The menu features classic diner fare, such as burgers, grilled sandwiches, hot dogs, and fries, as well as their homemade salad sandwiches. They have their famous French Toast to try as well! The restaurant also has a selection of homemade desserts, including pies, cakes, and specialty ice cream sundaes.
In addition to its food offerings, the Star Confectionery is also a candy store that sells a variety of homemade candies, chocolates, and fudge. They also have a selection of retro candies that will instantly take you back to your childhood. (631) 727-9873
Stirling Sake
Greenport
Stirling Sake is a renowned sake brewery with an array of sake and dishes to choose from. Located in Greenport, the restaurant prides itself on its sake making and the various flights they have to offer.
Stirling Sake has a delectable menu of different types of food and sake. The restaurant offers sushi dishes, rolls, temari, noodles, and shareable dishes. As for the assortment of sake, there are 6 flights to choose from. There is also a wine and beer menu for those looking for something different!
Stirling Sake is open for dinner with indoor and outdoor seating, as well as take-out. Reservations can be made online through their website or through phone. 631-477-6782
